Stories
Aunt Susan Finally Told Me Why My Mother Lost Her First Daughter — Episode 3
My aunt admitted that my mother had another daughter before me. But the part that broke me wasn't discovering I had a sister. It was learning that my mother spent years believing her first baby had died. My father knew the truth. My aunt knew the truth. And somehow, my brother Daniel had known enough to help keep it buried. When I demanded to know where Emily was, Susan pulled a folded letter from her handbag. It had been addressed to my mother twenty-six years earlier. The envelope had never...
Full story · Fiction
For several seconds, I couldn't make myself speak.
"Emily?" I finally repeated.
Aunt Susan stood beside the open storage compartment, holding the yellow envelope against her chest.
"Your mother had another daughter before you were born."
I looked at Daniel.
He was staring at the wooden floor of the boat.
"You knew I had a sister?"
He rubbed his forehead.
"I knew there had been a baby. I didn't know her name was Emily."
"How convenient."
"Claire, I was twenty-one when Dad told me."
"And you never thought to mention it?"
He didn't answer.
Susan slowly sat on the rear bench.
"Your mother was nineteen when she had Emily. She wasn't married yet. Your grandmother had already made it clear that having a child without a husband would bring shame to the family."
I looked at her.
"What happened to the baby?"
Susan swallowed.
"Rebecca was told Emily died shortly after birth."
The marina suddenly seemed very quiet.
"Told by whom?"
Susan looked toward the water.
"Your grandmother arranged everything through a private adoption agency. She said the baby wouldn't survive anyway. She convinced everyone that signing the papers was the kindest thing to do."
"Everyone? Including my mother?"
Susan nodded.
"Rebecca believed Emily had died. She was never shown adoption documents."
I held the photograph tighter.
"But you knew she was alive?"
"I found out later."
"How much later?"
Susan opened her handbag and removed the yellow envelope.
"Almost two years after the adoption."
She explained that she had been helping their mother clean out an old filing cabinet when she discovered a receipt from the adoption agency. There was a reference number, a date, and a handwritten note indicating that the child had been placed with a family.
Susan had confronted her mother.
At first, their mother denied everything.
Then she admitted that Emily had survived.
"Why didn't you tell Rebecca?" I asked.
Susan's eyes filled.
"I wanted to. Your grandmother threatened to tell everyone that Rebecca had willingly abandoned her baby. She said she would make sure nobody believed your mother if she tried to challenge the story."
"So you protected the person who did it?"
"I was afraid. I was twenty-three. I thought I could find Emily quietly and tell Rebecca once I had something certain."
I looked at the envelope.
"Did you find her?"
Susan nodded.
"Eventually."
Daniel finally looked up.
"Aunt Susan, don't."
I turned toward him.
"Don't what?"
He stood and walked toward the bow.
"This isn't as simple as she's making it sound."
Susan looked at him with an expression I couldn't understand.
"Your father asked me to stop searching."
"Why?" I demanded.
"Because Rebecca was pregnant again. She was carrying you. He believed finding Emily would destroy the life they were trying to build."
I shook my head.
"Dad let Mom believe her first child was dead so he could have a peaceful marriage?"
Susan didn't defend him.
That silence told me more than another explanation could have.
I looked at the envelope in her hands.
"What's inside?"
She hesitated.
"A letter I wrote to your mother. I never gave it to her."
"Why bring it now?"
"Because your father left instructions that I should give it to you if the boat was ever opened."
She placed it on the bench.
The envelope had faded at the corners. My mother's name was written across the front in Susan's handwriting.
I carefully opened it.
Inside was a short letter dated March 1999.
Susan had written that she had located the family who adopted Emily. She had confirmed the girl was healthy and living in a small town outside the state capital.
There was also a name.
Margaret and Thomas Collins.
Underneath, Susan had written:
I saw her today. She has Rebecca's eyes.
I read that sentence twice.
My mother had spent years believing her daughter was dead while Susan had actually seen her alive.
"Did Mom ever read this?"
Susan shook her head.
"No. I couldn't bring myself to give it to her."
"You had years."
"I know."
"She could have met her daughter. She could have held her. She could have known she was alive."
Susan began crying quietly.
"I know, Claire. I have thought about that every day."
For once, I didn't have an angry response ready.
I simply looked at the letter.
Then I noticed something written in the bottom corner.
A telephone number.
Beside it was a note in Dad's handwriting.
Contact only after Rebecca is gone.
I felt sick.
Dad hadn't simply hidden the past.
He had left instructions to keep hiding it after he died.
I looked at Daniel.
"Did you know about this number?"
He nodded slowly.
"Dad showed it to me about six years ago."
"Six years?"
"He said Emily had contacted him."
I stared at him.
"What?"
Daniel sat down.
He explained that Dad had received a letter from someone identifying herself as Emily Collins. She had apparently discovered information about her birth family and wanted to know whether Rebecca was alive.
Dad had answered her.
He told her that Rebecca had passed away.
That part was true.
But he also told her that her birth mother had never wanted contact.
That part wasn't true.
I felt my hands tighten around the paper.
"Did Emily believe him?"
Daniel nodded.
"He showed me her reply. She said she wouldn't disturb the family again."
"And you let me believe there was no sister?"
"Dad made me promise."
I stood up.
"You keep saying that as if promises excuse everything."
He didn't look at me.
I turned back to Susan.
"Is this number still active?"
She nodded.
"It's the number Emily gave me years ago. I never called it."
I took out my phone and photographed the letter.
Frank approached the boat from the dock.
"Claire, I think you should see something else."
He was carrying a small plastic sleeve.
Inside was a folded piece of paper with Dad's handwriting.
"I found this under the office filing cabinet after he died," Frank said. "I thought it was an old maintenance note. But after what you've shown me, I think it belongs to you."
I opened it.
There were only two sentences.
If Emily comes looking again, don't let Daniel answer the door.
She deserves to hear what happened from someone who wasn't paid to keep quiet.
I looked at my brother.
His face had gone pale.
"What does that mean?" I asked.
He stood abruptly.
"Give me that paper."
I pulled it away.
"Why?"
"Because you don't understand what happened."
"Then explain it."
He looked at Susan.
"Tell her about the money."
Susan closed her eyes.
I felt the anger returning.
"What money?"
Daniel finally faced me.
"Emily didn't just write Dad once. She contacted him three times. The last time, she asked for help paying for something."
"And?"
"Dad sent her money."
I looked at the payment records from the compartment.
The repeated payments to Susan suddenly made sense.
"You were sending her money through Aunt Susan?"
Daniel nodded.
"Dad wanted her to stay away. He thought financial help would make things easier."
Susan shook her head.
"That isn't the whole story."
Daniel turned toward her.
"Please don't."
She looked at me.
"Emily refused the money. She sent it back. Every time."
I stared at the payment list.
"Then where did the money go?"
Susan opened her handbag again.
She removed a small stack of bank receipts, tied together with an old rubber band.
"Your father asked me to deposit it into an account. He said it belonged to Emily."
"Did it?"
Susan looked at Daniel.
"The account wasn't in Emily's name."
Daniel took a step toward us.
"Aunt Susan, stop."
But she was already reaching for the final receipt.
She placed it in my hand.
The account holder's name was printed clearly across the top.
Daniel Bennett.
I looked at my brother.
He didn't deny it.
Instead, he reached into his jacket and pulled out his phone.
"Claire, there's a reason Dad told me to keep Emily away from this family. And if you call that number, you're going to find out why."
Before I could answer, my phone vibrated.
An unknown number had sent me a message.
There were only eleven words.
"Claire Bennett? My name is Emily. I think you're my sister."
Take a break. Sharpen your mind.
Trivia, word games, puzzles and more—fresh challenges are waiting every day.
Explore all gamesRelated Articles

My Sister Told Everyone I Abandoned Our Father — Then I Found the 47 Letters She Never Let Him Read | Episode 2: The Locked Drawer — Episode 2
My father gave me a brass key and told me to open the locked drawer in his study. My sister practically begged me not to. The next morning, I drove to our childhood home, expecting to find old photographs or family documents. Instead, I found 47 letters, every one written by me, every one still sealed. Some were birthday cards. Others contained photographs of my children my father had never seen. But beneath the letters was something far more disturbing: a document bearing my father's signatu...

My Brother Sold Our Mother's House While She Was Still Alive — Episode 3: The Woman My Father Trusted With His Biggest Secret — Episode 3
The next morning, I walked into my father's former attorney's office expecting answers about the $280,000 my brother had stolen. Instead, I discovered that my father had secretly appointed someone in our family to protect everything he left behind. It was Daniel's wife, Vanessa. She had been hiding the original documents for years, and she finally revealed why. But the biggest shock came when she showed me a photograph of my brother standing beside a man I'd never seen before. That man had he...

My Sister Told Everyone I Abandoned Our Father — Then I Found the 47 Letters She Never Let Him Read — Episode 1
My sister stood beside our father's hospital bed and told everyone I hadn't visited him in eleven months. She even showed our relatives a calendar proving I had forgotten his birthday, Thanksgiving, and Christmas. My father looked at me with tears in his eyes and whispered, "I thought you didn't love me anymore." I couldn't explain myself because I had no idea what she was talking about. Then a nurse handed me a dusty cardboard box she'd found in my father's locked desk. Inside were 47 unopen...
Recommended for You

My Sister Told Everyone I Abandoned Our Father — Then I Found the 47 Letters She Never Let Him Read | Episode 5: The Truth That Finally Brought Us Home — Episode 5
My sister had spent eleven months keeping my letters from our father, but the biggest betrayal was still waiting. An amendment bearing Dad's forged signature had transferred control of our family inheritance, and my biological mother had apparently signed it too. Then we discovered Vanessa had secretly contacted Laura eleven months earlier. The two women had made an arrangement neither Dad nor I knew about. When Laura finally walked into the room, she was carrying something that changed every...

My Sister Told Everyone I Abandoned Our Father — Then I Found the 47 Letters She Never Let Him Read | Episode 4: The Promise Mom Made Me Break — Episode 4
My sister finally admitted that our biological mother had returned when I was six years old. But the truth was worse than I imagined. My mother Margaret hadn't simply rejected her younger sister. She had made a secret arrangement that kept Laura away from me for decades. Then Vanessa confessed that she had personally helped destroy Laura's attempts to contact us. I thought that was the worst betrayal. Until my attorney discovered that someone had been quietly withdrawing money from a family t...

My Sister Told Everyone I Abandoned Our Father — Then I Found the 47 Letters She Never Let Him Read | Episode 3: The Mother I Never Knew — Episode 3
I spent 42 years believing Margaret Mitchell was the woman who gave birth to me. Then an anonymous email showed me a hospital record with another woman's name. My sister Vanessa knew something about it, and my father had apparently spent his entire life protecting the secret. But the biggest shock came when I finally played the USB recording hidden beneath my father's letters. My mother's voice filled the room. What she said explained why my sister had been so desperate to keep me away. And t...
Join the discussion
No comments yet. Start the conversation.